Why Your Online Course Is Not Selling and How to Fix It

Why Your Online Course Is Not Selling and How to Fix It

Is your online course not selling? You can fix that. I started my online business in 2014, and I had no idea how to sell online. After 9 months I still did not know how to sell my online courses. I knew I had to change something, so I decided to learn how to sell online.

By 2023 I had made $15 million in revenue in my online business, and over $8 million of that from online course sales alone. I love selling online courses, and I love teaching my clients how to create and sell them. But first I made all the common mistakes.

Mistake 1: No Offer at the End

The first time I offered an online course, I made it free. 134 people signed up in a week, and I was so happy. It was a 7-day course with daily assignments, and it was quite intense. During the course I realised it should have been a 4-week course, and later I changed that.

At the end I got dozens of testimonials. The participants were happy, and I was happy too. I had created my first online course and I was super proud.

Then I made a big mistake. I did not make an offer at the end. The participants left my world happy and probably bought something from someone else. Not making an offer to an engaged audience is probably the biggest mistake you can make.

Mistake 2: Thinking an Email List Is Ready to Buy

Later that year I wanted to sell my course, now as a 4-week course. I had an email list with a few hundred email addresses, and I wrote regular newsletters. I thought I had an engaged audience that was ready to buy.

I sent a few emails and made a few social media posts. I did the same a few times during the year. At the end of the year I had sold 17 spots and made just over $3,000 (about €2,300). That was not sustainable. Having an email list does not mean your subscribers are ready to buy.

Mistake 3: Selling Something No One Asked For

Towards the end of my first year I finally learned how to sell on a webinar. I learned to launch, and I was so excited. 600 people signed up for my webinar. I made them an offer for a new online course I wanted to create.

Luckily I had not created it yet, because only 1 person bought, and I refunded her. I had offered my audience a course that literally no one had asked for. I had just assumed it was what they wanted. You cannot sell people something they do not want to buy.

Lesson 1: Selling Is a Numbers Game

You need enough people interested in the first place. My first free course had 134 sign-ups. With a typical conversion rate of 3%, that is about 4 potential clients. And of course you have to make an offer to get those sales.

Many course creators are disappointed when they hear the average conversion rate is only 3%. Many of my students tell me they only sold a few spots of their online course. When I show them that their conversion rate is above average, they realise they did a good job. Knowing that 3% is normal helps you set the right expectations.

Lesson 2: Sell People What They Want

You can only sell people what they want to buy. So find out what they want, and then give it to them. Sometimes it is exactly what you wanted to offer anyway. Sometimes you have to adjust a bit.

Sell people what they want, and then give them what they need. I have a course called Sales Every Day. The title is exactly what my students want: they want to sell their online course every day. Inside the program I teach them what they need to know and do to actually have sales every day. I could have called it Online Business Foundations, but that is not what they want to buy.

Lesson 3: You Need Engaged People to Sell

An email list is not engaged enough to sell many spots of your online course, even with weekly newsletters. A few emails and a few social media posts are not enough. You need a marketing campaign that engages people with your content and then sells your course.

There are 2 ways to sell an online course:

  • A launch, which is a marketing campaign where you sell a lot of spots in one go
  • An evergreen funnel, a sales funnel where you also sell many spots, but over a longer time

In both cases you first need to engage your audience so they are ready to buy. A great way to do that is a freebie or a low-priced program. With a freebie it is easier to get a lot of sign-ups. With a low-priced program you get a buyer, and a buyer is a buyer. Both work, and I recommend my students use both.

Frequently asked questions

Why is my online course not selling?

The common mistakes are not making an offer at the end, thinking your email list is ready to buy, and selling something no one asked for. I made all 3 myself.

What is a normal conversion rate for an online course?

The average conversion rate is 3%. So if 134 people sign up, that is about 4 potential clients. Knowing that 3% is normal helps you set the right expectations.

Is an email list enough to sell my online course?

No. Having an email list does not mean your subscribers are ready to buy, even with weekly newsletters. You need a marketing campaign, a launch or an evergreen funnel, that engages people with your content and then sells your course.

How do I know what online course to sell?

You can only sell people what they want to buy, so find out what they want and give it to them. Sell people what they want, and then give them what they need.

Sigrun Gudjonsdottir

About the author

Sigrun Gudjonsdottir

Sigrun helps smart female entrepreneurs build AI-first companies. She has trained 233,041 women, worked with 10,000 clients and generated over €23M in revenue. In April 2026, she closed all her programs and is now turning 13 years of proven business methodology into AI agents. She is the host of The SIGRUN Show and the bestselling author of Kickstart Your Online Business.